Food History: Why We Eat Pie at Thanksgiving


When we think of Thanksgiving, we tend to think of football, turkey, and pumpkin pie. As Lions fans, we’re perpetually underwhelmed by our Thanksgiving football viewing, which puts an awful lot of pressure on the turkey and pumpkin pie. Thinking about the emphasis on food at Thanksgiving dinner got me thinking - how did pumpkin pie become so synonymous with Thanksgiving? When did pumpkin pie become associated with the holiday? And why pumpkin pie and not, for example, apple pie? 

With ample time and a curious mind, I set forth to set the record straight about pumpkin pie and its relationship with Turkey Day. 

Pumpkin Pie’s Seasonal Connection to Thanksgiving

Pumpkin pie is ubiquitous at Thanksgiving dinners around the country. An estimated 50 million pumpkin pies will be consumed on Thanksgiving Day alone. A huge contributing factor to pumpkin pie’s popularity at Thanksgiving is simple due to timing. Most pumpkin growers harvest their crop by late October. Nowadays, most folks aren’t buying pumpkins from the patch for their pies, but centuries-old traditions die hard. 

The Importance of Pumpkins and Gourds to Native Americans

If we think pumpkins are a big deal to us at Thanksgiving, this pales in comparison to how important pumpkins and gourds were to Native Americans across North America. Native Americans have been growing pumpkins and squash for 9,000 years before Europeans made their way to the Western Hemisphere. Pumpkins and squash were such important staples to Native American diets that these foods were often highly-revered and sacred in cultures across North America. 

How the Tradition Started

Now that we know that late fall is prime harvest season for pumpkins and that these foods were massively important to Native Americans, it’s no surprise that pumpkins played a big role in Thanksgiving. When settlers arrived in Plymouth in 1620, Native American tribes brought pumpkins as gifts and taught them how to properly prepare them for stews and pies. The importance of pumpkins (and squash) and Thanksgiving has been a part of the tradition ever since. 

As it turns out, pumpkin pie is an excellent reminder of the incredibly important role Native Americans played in the formation of our traditions, even lasting into our modern era. 

Now for the big question; pumpkin pie or apple pie? Now with a little more history, you may have more of an inclination to give the nod to the pie that was a gift from Native Americans from centuries past! 


There are currently no comments

New Comment


required (not published)














RSS / Atom

Max's Service

135 East State Street
Traverse City, MI   49684

Phone: (231) 947-6830

Store Hours

Sales   8:30am-6pm
Office and Parts   8am-5pm 
Service  8am-5pm


Sales   9am-4pm